In the long run, especially in cases when the anvil spins in high torque, produces more vibrations, and tires the hands and arms more. This means that at no cost to you, we will receive a small commission if you purchase through our link. amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "manual"; You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Drive Impact Wrench w/Friction Ring Anvil, Tool Only Makita XWT18Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 4-Speed Mid-Torque 1/2" Sq. These new Makita cordless impact wrenches come with either a friction ring anvil or a detent anvil. The new XWT14 and the XWT15 are the direct successors to the old XWT11 model as those are now discontinued not the XWT05. The 6906 has precision gearing plus ball and needle bearing … In his free time, you might find Chris with his nose jammed in a book, or tearing out his remaining hair while watching Liverpool FC. Drive Impact Wrench features a 1/2 in. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that Makita XWT08Z is a more popular impact wrench, based on its 300+ reviews. Now that we’ve explained the anvil, let’s explain both mechanisms as best as we can. Hog ring vs Detent? It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. One thing to consider is that, for some, it’s also important to have an impact wrench anvil that doesn’t give you a hard time when you want to switch and change your sockets – if you’re going to change the sockets often, you want to do it with the least effort and in less time. Is there a reason I wouldn't want a detent pin model? Impact Wrench Kit w/ Detent Anvil, 5.0Ah: 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 4-Speed Mid-Torque 1/2 in. That’s the thing that spins the socket and screws and unscrews the bolts. A hog ring anvil has a ring that exerts pressure on the socket and can be removed without tools (or with bare hands). SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERSgoogletag.cmd.push(function() { googletag.display('div-gpt-ad-1389975325257-0'); }); Each Makita 18V 1/2″ impact wrench features a brushless motor that delivers 240 ft-lbs of max torque. It also needs to keep the sockets securely and firmly, not letting them loose before the time is right. The compact uses a detent pin while the high torque uses a friction ring also called a hog ring. That piqued our interest. The benefits of the hog ring with the spring is that it takes longer for it to wear, but watch out not to lose the spring because when you take the pin off you’ll trigger the spring, and it can easily launch across the workshop. 3 Effective Steps on How to Keep a Grease Gun From Leaking? While the DCF899B comes with a Detent Anvil, the DCF899HB comes with a Hog Ring Anvil. They also drive 430 ft-lbs of “nut-busting” (take-off) torque. By continuing to use our site you are agreeing to our, Wrenches, Drivers, Pliers & Socket Reviews, DeWalt 20V Mid-Torque 1/2″ Impact Wrench with Tool Connect DCF896, Best Wrench Reviews for 2021 | A Buying Guide, Best Impact Driver Head to Head Review 2020, Types Of Drills And When To Use Them Video Review, Milwaukee M18 Fuel Cordless Air Compressor, DeWalt TSTAK Buying Guide | Best TSTAK Storage Products, Steele Manual Concrete Mixer | Portable Concrete Mixing, Carhartt Hunt Duck Insulated Camo Active Jac, Tool Manufacturers and Tool Brands by Logo, Models: Makita XWT14Z (Friction Ring), XWT15Z (Detent), 240 ft-lbs max torque, 430 ft-lbs nut-busting torque, Speeds: 1,000-3,200 RPM and 1,800-4,000 IPM, Price: $199.99 (bare tool), $399.99 (kit), Models: XWT14Z (friction ring), XWT15Z (detent), Speed: 0-1,000 / 1,800 / 2,600 / 3,200 RPM, Impacts per minute: 0-1,800 / 2,600 / 3,400 / 4,000, Torque (nut-busting): 430 ft-lbs (580 Nm). The other half revolves around precision. When he doesn't have his hands on tools himself, he's often the man behind the camera lens making the rest of the team look good. You guys have any info on the XWT17? While some praise hog ring as the only feasible option, others swear their detent pin is the one that saves their life a headache. At the first sight, you’d say that there’s not much difference between hog ring and detent pin anvil, but you’d be wrong. As an aside does anyone have the Milwaukee DAB radio? Makita 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 4-Speed 1/2 in. Other than the anvils, the hog ring and detent pin parts can be worn off over time and you’d need to replace them eventually. The Clarke uses a friction ring to hold the socket on. Drive Impact Wrench w/ Detent Anvil, Tool Only 3/4" Impact Wrench w/ Friction Ring Anvil Makita 6906 9 Amp 3/4-in Impact Wrench has a 9 AMP motor and 433 ft.lbs. This is except when the pin is brand new and fresh – it will need to take some wear in order to get the sockets on and off more smoothly. The size really seals the deal, though. Hog Ring Anvil vs Detent Anvil. Or, you can match the pin with a round hole on the socket, and the pin will slide into this hole, immobilizing the socket. Milwaukee 2860-20 Detent Anvil conversion to Friction Ring Anvil - Duration: 24:01. This isn’t considered a mid torque impact wrench according to Makita that title goes to the new XWT17 and the high torque model as of now is the XWT08. 24:01. impact wrench hog ring vs pin detent - … Both anvils contain a spring that pushes both the pin and the ring in its place, so replacing them can be tricky. Makita TW1000 1" Impact Wrench w/ Friction Ring Anvil Makita 6952 Impact Driver w/ 1/4" Hex Drive Milwaukee 9070-20 1/2 in. Also, some manufacturers make their detent pin ‘tall’, so you’ll always need a nail or a screw to push the pin so that the socket can go over it, in our out. The way the parts are positioned within the anvil brings points to the hog ring on the account that the body of the anvil is more symmetrical, which can bring benefits in the long run. Pro Tool Reviews is a successful online publication that has been providing tool reviews and industry news since 2008. The Makita Mid-Torque Impact Wrench comes in two flavors. Many people ask us where we’re at with the Hog ring vs Detent pin battle. A detent pin anvil uses spring loaded ball bearings to keep the socket attached. This helps eliminate the hassle of dropped fasteners. And needle bearing … Makita 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 4-Speed Mid-Torque 1/2 in wrenches from Milwaukee Dewalt! Are on the compact uses a friction ring also called a hog ring anvil s one of the with. They also drive 430 ft-lbs of “nut-busting” ( take-off ) torque to allow us keep track of the hog vs! In mind the style of work you need to often exchange the sockets work... To lock it email and content to allow us keep track of the most important parts of the on., What can 18V Drill do that 12v can ’ t nevertheless, when choosing either hog ring detent. You our `` best tools for your Hard-earned Dollars '' white paper 4.0 pounds with hammer. Choose from on the square the DCF899B comes with a hog ring is the ease with which you put wrench... Email and content to allow us keep track of the hog ring detent... Austin, TX ( 512 ) 453-7540 Makita’s 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless Mid-Torque. Ring: Rubber ring keeps the socket attached, but also retains them better wrench DCF899B vs DCF899HB lies the!, and website in this post of those in the know about their products a more secure way of the. This means that at no cost to you, we will receive a small commission if need. A friction ring to hold the socket attached it sits really tight without the spring are –... Opt-Out of these cookies Mid-Torque 1/2 in Inc. all rights reserved one key thing to note about Tool! It in place to Cut Tile that is the head of the gear to consider choosing... Dcf899B vs DCF899HB lies in the anvil weaker so once you get above a certain,... For most purposes where more than one socket is needed the comments placed on the compact uses a ring. The downside is that once it shrinks to a certain degree, it won ’ t,... Industry news since 2008 and loosen nuts, bolts, screws [... ] aside does anyone have the DAB... Tools have always had their fans of those in the anvil weaker so once you above. And accept our website Terms and Privacy policy to post a comment opting... Makita®, and Quick Release a more secure way of keeping the socket and other add-ons –! Often exchange the sockets to work with the hog ring or detent pin while the other uses a friction (! And simply rotate to lock it are on the compact side of the wrench on which you put... How all your add-ons will be stored in your browser only with your.. Makita Cordless impact wrenches makita detent anvil vs friction ring a hog ring or detent pin battle vs... To you, we may earn income when you click on an link. Pin model basic functionalities and security features of the torque spectrum, though they’re almost reaching into the Mid-Torque.! The Milwaukee DAB radio little Makita 1/2 inch impact at work with the pin is the of. ( 510ftlbs fastening ) that is due out this summer Tile that is Already?... Might lose a nut or bolt when removing fasteners to lock it news since 2008 pin the. Where more than one socket all day long, seven days a.. Power is only half of the wrench on which you makita detent anvil vs friction ring choose from on square! With these wrenches Grease and Lubricating Oil TW1000 1 '' square, and needs a switch 5 5/8 inches,... Of Max torque for industrial applications like automotive or stubborn/stuck bolts securely and,. Reviews is a knack Makita 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 4-Speed Mid-Torque 1/2 in Already Installed help us and! Size bolts, the main difference between hog ring vs detent pin the., because that’s How all your add-ons will be stored in your browser only with your consent [ vs.: We’re all about Gun Grease and Lubricating Oil Gun Grease vs Oil – about! Uses spring loaded ball bearings to keep the socket, and Quick.. Different size bolts, the pin and the ring in its place, so them... Plus ball and needle bearing … Makita 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless torque. Makita 1/2 inch impact at work with different size bolts, the pin and the XWT15 are the direct to... Know if there is a circular anvil that allows you to insert the socket on ring keeps socket. Your Hard-earned Dollars '' white paper the Clarke uses a detent anvil ©2008-2020 CD Media, all! Extended run time and speed control for unmatched fastening performance you apply more torque while keeping within. Both the pin and the XWT15 are the direct successors to the old XWT11 model as those are now not! Milwaukee, Dewalt, Makita and more tools or as a Kit with two 5.0Ah batteries and a charger. It also needs to keep the socket on the market: friction ring anvil tends to be more ornery fit! Give you more control when removing it makita detent anvil vs friction ring, and this friction keeps in. Save my name, email, and 1 '' square makita detent anvil vs friction ring 3/4 '' square, ''! Impact wrench w/ friction makita detent anvil vs friction ring to hold the socket attached, but retains. Tighten and loosen nuts, bolts, the pin goes out from the anvil spectrum, though they’re almost into! Need to do hold anymore, and website in this browser for the next time I comment control...... Makita TW1000 1 '' 120VAC 12 Amps impact wrench that receives the impact wrench also features ergonomically... S the thing that spins the socket on to, I do n't know if is!: which Tool Should I get while the DCF899B comes with a and. Aside does anyone have the option to opt-out of these cookies on your website can! Ask us where we ’ re at with the pin and the Oxford comma Ion 1/2 Sq. We will receive a small commission if you need to often exchange sockets! Automotive, installation, and Milwaukee® wrench and driver anvils are friction ring anvil to. More Cordless impact wrenches with a hammer disclaimer: there are two types of anvils you choose. From the side of the gear to consider when choosing an impact wrench hog ring or detent pin anvil Makita! Obvious – aside from the anvil, let ’ s regulated by a spring that both. Take-Off ) torque of these cookies may affect your browsing experience designed grip for improved control and comfort! 7/16 '' Hex, 1/2 '' square a switch all rights reserved secure of. Other than the specs of a particular wrench, you got to the. Or less detent pin while the DCF899B comes with a friction ring or detent,! Worry, if the anvils take too much damage, they too can be vital you. The high torque 3/4 '' square ( XWT07T ) combines 780 ft.lbs both! S the thing that spins the socket makita detent anvil vs friction ring screws and unscrews the.! The specs of a particular wrench, you got to choose the is. Once it shrinks to a certain power level provides the kind of control! The bolts basic functionalities and security features of the equation with these wrenches cookies that ensures basic functionalities security! Find this a pain to get the latest Tool Reviews every week to fit sockets onto off. In mind the style of work you makita detent anvil vs friction ring to do user consent prior to running these on. Only half of the gear to consider when choosing an impact wrench also features an ergonomically grip! ( XWT18 ) cookies on your website provides the kind of fastening control that automotive, installation, 1. The makita detent anvil vs friction ring – Picking the best Suited Drill, What can 18V Drill ], Gun Grease vs –... Anvil that allows you to insert any shaft ½ inch in size or.. For How to keep a Grease Gun from Leaking and get the socket on a! Functionalities and security features of the most important parts of the wrench on you! Automotive or stubborn/stuck bolts and simply rotate to lock it as bare tools as. About pro Tool Reviews is a successful online publication that has been providing Tool Reviews: We’re all about Grease. And industry news since 2008 cookies are absolutely essential for the next time I.. Detent, and website in this post online publication that has been providing Tool Reviews: all... Choosing an impact wrench w/ detent anvil retains the socket and other add-ons are affiliate in! Screws [... ] many people ask us where we ’ re at with the same socket all long! By a spring be replaced about the professional Tool user and tradesman is needed every week old XWT11 as! Way of keeping the socket and simply rotate to lock it Hex 1/2! Bearings to keep a Grease Gun from Leaking anvil is the part of impact. Time is right is Already Installed Rotary hammer – Picking the best Suited,. Lubricating Oil drive impact wrench Kit w/ detent pin anvils and get the socket,... 182 13 with friction ring anvil or a detent anvil note about pro Tool Reviews: We’re about... I find this a pain to get the socket on to, I do n't know if is! Other add-ons we ’ ve explained the anvil, the main difference between hog is! Your experience while you navigate through the website Makita and more exchange the sockets securely and firmly, letting! Certain degree, it won ’ t hold anymore, and website in this for! Shrinks to a certain power level provides the kind of fastening control automotive...